4 answers |
Liberals are dictator?I saw a comment from a media said that Liberals are dictator that don't accept criticism, see the downvote as the proof. And when there's no downvote he said that what he say is right? It seems that he interpret to win every situation in the first p... |
3 answers |
No true scotsmanI have a problem with the No true Scotsman fallacy. I fail to distinguish it from a modens tollens. Take this famous argument for example: Person A: "No Scotsman puts sugar on his porridge." Person B: "But my uncle Angus is a Scotsman and he puts s... |
4 answers |
Any logical fallacy in Pete Buttigieg's rhetoric on abortion?Pete Buttigieg said this about limits on late-term abortion: "I think the dialogue has gotten so caught up on where you draw the line, that we've gotten away from the fundamental question of who gets to draw the line, and I trust women to draw the l... |
2 answers |
Question about unfalsifiability fallacy.What is the difference between an unfalsifiable argument, a defeasible argument and a indefeasible argument? Are they all the unfalsifiability fallacy? |
8 answers |
Is my teacher wrong?Teacher: why weren't you in school Me: my stomach was hurting so I stayed home Teacher: prove your stomach hurt Me: That's impossible because there's no way to prove my stomach hurt, besides me saying that my stomach hurt Teacher: so then ... |
5 answers |
Is this a non-sequiturI saw this argument floating on reddit and wanted to know whether it commits the non-sequitur fallacy or not 1. Affirmative action is racist against Asians because it creates unfairness to them based on their race. 2. Asian Americans who support af... |
5 answers |
Hate speech argument fallacy?I can't quite put my finger on it but I can't help but think this argumentative statement is fallacious: Hate speech cannot be made illegal in a consistent way: outlawing hate speech would be an expression of hatred towards hate speech, wh... |
4 answers |
If you do X correctly you will never make a mistake.One of my jobs is operating a wood chipper. Sometimes it gets clogged and takes an hour of painstaking work to unclog. My boss told me that if I fed branches into the chipper correctly it would never get clogged. This mostly sounds... |
3 answers |
AbortionI think the current understanding of "my body, my choice" is misplaced. Pregnancy is not a choice, it is one of the possible consequences of choosing to have sex. "My body, my choice" should be applied to the choice of having sex. What ... |
2 answers |
Does this come off as a slothful induction?From here : “National sex education standards right now for K-3 say that gender ideology, that those children need to know by third grade that you can be a boy or a girl, neither or both,” Descovich said. “That is very concerning... |