Want to get notified of all questions as they are asked? Update your mail preferences and turn on "Instant Notification."
Get all EIGHT of Bo's printed books, all autographed*. Save over $50!
* This offer is for residents of United States and Canada only.
|
I think it's just a non sequitur. There's no logical connection between the two statements. Consider 1) I am a woman 2) Therefore, I speak for women. What's the relationship between 1 and 2? There isn't one. To speak for a group means that you represent the views held by its members, but if the group is sufficiently heterogenous (like women in the above example) then simply being a member of that group means that your view is just one of many, which indicates that you do not in fact represent the group. Institutions might have spokespeople who are given the responsibility of speaking for a group. But they will be much more homogenous than a group based on mere identity. And even then, the spokespeople will often be told what to say, rather than giving an opinion and claiming it as that of the institution. |
answered on Monday, Jul 15, 2024 01:22:09 PM by TrappedPrior (RotE) | |
TrappedPrior (RotE) Suggested These Categories |
|
Comments |
|
|
|
Assuming that this person is being truthful about being a member of the group, I could see this being used in one of two ways. One is that the group is small. Maybe you have spoken to every person in your department at work, or on your soccer team, and you can truthfully say that every person in the group agrees with what you're saying. Another is when you're talking about a large demographic group. For instance, "I speak for men when I say beer is better than wine ." It's highly unlikely that the person has spoken to the entire group, or that there is a consensus. In that case, the person would likely be relying on their own experience, that of people they've met or seen in the media, etc. In which case they'd likely be committing the hasty generalization fallacy. |
answered on Monday, Jul 15, 2024 05:19:56 PM by Mr. Wednesday | |
Mr. Wednesday Suggested These Categories |
|
Comments |
|
|