1 answers |
Weak Analogy?Telling miracles are natural things is just like saying when you don't have your phone in your pocket you say it's natural rather than theif while you don't know where your phone is. |
4 answers |
Detect the logical fallacy hereIn Hyde Park, England there is an area called Speakers' Corner where open-air public speaking takes place. Sometimes the various debates get really heated but no one is harmed. Recently, however, during a debate, a Christian apologist was stabbed, a... |
1 answers |
Is this a logical fallacy?When you are going through something hard and wonder where god is, remember that teacher is always quite during a test. |
4 answers |
Fallacy?1. There is no reason to love someone who doesn't love you back. 2. Mother loves her children but children doesn't love her. 3. Therefore mother shouldn't love their children |
0 answers |
Strong argument or a logical fallacy1. Samantha claims that you should believe that muhammad splitted the moon. 2. Harris claims that I won't trust this because it has no evidence. 3. Samantha tells that when you see that when people tell that Ptolemy did this and that because they ... |
3 answers |
What errors in reasoning do we see here? "Free-will FALSIFIES Materialism & ATHEISM"The argument goes thus : P1. If atheism is true, then materialism is necessarily true (and vice versa). P2. If materialism is true, then determinism is necessarily true. And if so, free-will is impossible. P3. However, it is totally obvious (beyon... |
2 answers |
Is this an example of parodying circular reasoning, or it is an example of circular reasoning itself?"I've got an expert, you've got an expert, everyone's got an expert, but we don't know what the criteria for an expert is, unless you ask an expert." |
1 answers |
Fallacy?1. Max tells ressurection jesus is a miracle! 2. Samuel claims that there is possibility that may have happened due to some natural phenomena so miracles aren't the only possibility 3. Max claims that how do you know that mobiles are created by hu... |
1 answers |
Is this a logical fallacy?1. Person 1 claims that universe is created by god. 2. Person 2 claims that universe is created by green turtles. 3. Person 1 then asks why is the shape of the green turtle is like turtle shaped? 4. Person 2 reply by saying it's the same reason y... |
1 answers |
If a premise is incoherent, is the conclusion invalid?If a premise is incoherent, is the conclusion automatically invalid? Coherent premise : "Dogs have 4 legs", "Cats are not dogs", "Houses are over 5' tall", etc Incoherent premise : "Blue is greater than 10", "Apples are oranges", 2+5=78, etc ... |
